Bill Gates' 'laboratory' comment sparks controversy in India

Bill Gates' choice of words has quickly provoked criticism, with many accusing him of viewing India as nothing more than a testing ground for global projects.

By  Storyboard18| Dec 3, 2024 3:24 PM
During the podcast, Bill Gates made the comment while discussing India's progress in health, education, and nutrition, noting that the country was "stable enough" and had the capacity to generate its own government revenue. (Image source: Forbes)

Bill Gates, the co-founder of Microsoft, has found himself at the center of a heated debate following his recent appearance on Reid Hoffman's podcast, as per reports.

His comments, which referred to India as a "laboratory to try things," have drawn sharp criticism, especially from Indian commentators who have taken offense to the analogy.

While Gates intended to highlight India's role in global development, the remark has triggered widespread outrage, particularly on social media.

During the podcast, Gates made the comment while discussing India's progress in health, education, and nutrition, noting that the country was "stable enough" and had the capacity to generate its own government revenue. He emphasized that in the next 20 years, India's development would significantly improve. "It's kind of a laboratory to try things that then when you prove them out in India, you can take to other places," Gates remarked.

He went on to explain that the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation's largest non-U.S. office is located in India.

Gates' choice of words has sparked immediate backlash, with many accusing him of treating India as a mere testing ground for global initiatives.

On social media platforms, critics expressed frustration over his characterization of the country.

One user on X (formerly Twitter) said, "India is a laboratory, and we Indians are guinea pigs for Bill Gates." Others echoed this sentiment, suggesting that Gates viewed India as subjects for experimentation, with successful initiatives being implemented in the US.

"These human beings in India are samples for Bill Gates' laboratory to try things, and once they are proven effective, taken to the US," wrote another user.

However, not all reactions were negative. Some defended Gates, arguing that his comment had been misinterpreted.

Gates’ recent remarks come as a surprise, considering his history of praising India for its achievements.

In an earlier interview with PTI, Gates lauded India’s efforts to tackle malnutrition, noting that despite its income level, the country was focused on improving nutritional indicators. He commended India’s frankness in addressing these issues, even giving the country an "A" for its commitment to fighting malnutrition.

First Published onDec 3, 2024 3:24 PM

SPOTLIGHT

How it WorksMIB’s Ashwini Vaishnaw at Storyboard18 DNPA Conclave: Govt working for fair compensation for media houses

At the Storyboard18 DNPA Conclave 2025, Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw spotlighted the critical role of traditional media in an evolving digital landscape. He emphasized that such gatherings can aid the govt in formulating more effective policies for a balanced and sustainable media ecosystem.

Read More

IN PHOTOS: At Global Pioneers Summit, visionaries chart the future of business and creativity

From the chiefs of Nestle, Diageo, Colgate, PepsiCo, Zetwerk and CRED to AI visionaries, marketing mavens, top creators, ad legends and leading global agencies' CEOs, the brightest minds converged at the Storyboard18 Global Pioneers Summit for an action-packed day of meaningful dialogues on creativity, commerce and culture.