Honasa Consumer takes HUL to Delhi HC, seeks removal of Lakmé sunscreen Ad

The dispute centers around a battle between HUL’s Lakmé and Honasa’s Mamaearth over sunscreen effectiveness — and allegations of imitation.

By  Storyboard18Apr 16, 2025 11:46 AM
Honasa Consumer takes HUL to Delhi HC, seeks removal of Lakmé sunscreen Ad
While the ad didn’t explicitly name any brands, it featured two unbranded sunscreen bottles that bore a strong resemblance to products from Mamaearth’s The Derma Co. and Nykaa’s Dot & Key.

A new brand rivalry has emerged under the intense summer spotlight, as Honasa Consumer Ltd., the parent company of Mamaearth, has filed a lawsuit against Hindustan Unilever Ltd. (HUL), accusing the FMCG giant of brand mimicry and demanding the removal of its latest ad campaign. According to sources, the first court hearing is scheduled for Wednesday afternoon.

The dispute centers around a battle between HUL’s Lakmé and Honasa’s Mamaearth over sunscreen effectiveness — and allegations of imitation.

The feud began when Lakmé launched a new marketing campaign for its SPF 50 sunscreen, Lakmé Sun Expert. The campaign introduced a dramatized concept called the “SPF Lie Detector Test,” which suggested that some “online bestsellers” significantly exaggerated their SPF claims. While the ad didn’t explicitly name any brands, it featured two unbranded sunscreen bottles that bore a strong resemblance to products from Mamaearth’s The Derma Co. and Nykaa’s Dot & Key.

Lakmé claimed the ad was based on in vivo testing — a globally recognized gold standard for evaluating sunscreen effectiveness — conducted at an independent, accredited lab. According to the company, while its product met the advertised SPF 50 level, others tested delivered as little as SPF 20.

Mamaearth responded quickly. co-founder Ghazal Alagh took to social media to publicly accuse Lakmé and its parent company, HUL, of copying not only Mamaearth’s sunscreen but also other products, such as its vitamin C face wash and onion shampoo. In a now-deleted post, Alagh shared side-by-side images and launch timelines under the headline “OG vs Copy” to support her claims.

“Indian FMCG has lacked strong competition for a long time,” Alagh wrote in another post that is still online. “We take pride in challenging these norms and repeatedly waking up legacy brands.”

In an exclusive statement to Storyboard18, HUL defended its product and advertising, stating that its sunscreen claims are thoroughly validated. “Since 2015, we’ve conducted in vivo SPF testing across our sun care portfolio,” said an HUL spokesperson. The company also asserted that several popular sunscreen brands have been “falsely claiming SPF 50.”

“In the interest of consumers, independent lab testing has shown that some of these products fall significantly short of their stated SPF levels,” the spokesperson added. “This misleads consumers and poses potential skin risks, including pigmentation, premature aging, and dark spots. Indian consumers deserve access to sunscreens they can trust.”

First Published on Apr 16, 2025 11:34 AM

More from Storyboard18

How it Works

Zee Entertainment sells Hyderabad property for Rs 99 cr amid strategic asset monetisation

Zee Entertainment sells Hyderabad property for Rs 99 cr amid strategic asset monetisation

How it Works

44% of India’s smartphone sales in 2024 came from Gen Z: Report

44% of India’s smartphone sales in 2024 came from Gen Z: Report

How it Works

60% not familiar with AI; only 31% have tried a Gen AI tool: Google-Kantar report

60% not familiar with AI; only 31% have tried a Gen AI tool: Google-Kantar report

Brand Makers

Unilever sees strong growth prospects in India, driven by market share gains, favorable economic factors: CFO Srinivas Phatak

Unilever sees strong growth prospects in India, driven by market share gains, favorable economic factors: CFO Srinivas Phatak

How it Works

I&B Ministry asks OTT platforms to enhance accessibility features for persons with disabilities

I&B Ministry asks OTT platforms to enhance accessibility features for persons with disabilities

How it Works

Pakistan Super League faces uncertainty as Pakistan govt sends back Indian broadcast crew

Pakistan Super League faces uncertainty as Pakistan govt sends back Indian broadcast crew

How it Works

ED detains Gensol's Puneet Singh Jaggi in alleged money laundering case; conducts searches against firm

ED detains Gensol's Puneet Singh Jaggi in alleged money laundering case; conducts searches against firm

How it Works

Media buying disruption prompts brands to explore AI Agents

Media buying disruption prompts brands to explore AI Agents