U.S. Judge dismisses lawsuit challenging Amazon Prime Video ads

Subscribers alleged Amazon misled them by adding ads to Prime Video without consent. A federal judge ruled the move was legally permissible under Amazon's subscriber terms.

By  Storyboard18| Jul 17, 2025 11:26 AM
The plaintiffs - Prime subscribers paying $139 annually - claimed they were misled into believing the service would remain ad-free. (Image credits: Unsplash)

A U.S. federal judge on Wednesday dismissed a proposed class action lawsuit that challenged Amazon.com's decision to introduce advertisements on its Prime Video service unless users opted out by paying an additional $2.99 per month.

As reported by Reuters, the plaintiffs - Prime subscribers paying $139 annually - claimed they were misled into believing the service would remain ad-free.

They argued that the addition of ads constituted a price hike, breaching Amazon's user agreements and violating Washington state's consumer protection laws.

However, U.S. District Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein in Seattle ruled that Amazon had acted within its rights. She concluded the ads represented a "benefit modification" that was explicitly contemplated and allowed under the company's terms of service. The change, announced in late 2023, took effect in January 2024.

Lawyers representing the subscribers did not immediately respond to requests for comment, Reuters added.

First Published onJul 17, 2025 11:26 AM

SPOTLIGHT

Special CoverageCalling India’s Boldest Brand Makers: Entries Open for the Storyboard18 Awards for Creativity

From purpose-driven work and narrative-rich brand films to AI-enabled ideas and creator-led collaborations, the awards reflect the full spectrum of modern creativity.

Read More

“Confusion creates opportunity for agile players,” Sir Martin Sorrell on industry consolidation

Looking ahead to the close of 2025 and into 2026, Sorrell sees technology platforms as the clear winners. He described them as “nation states in their own right”, with market capitalisations that exceed the GDPs of many countries.