InspiRAYtion 15 - All criticism must be preceded by possession. The Jaguar canard

Brands are our collective aspirations; our hopes and dreams, our line in the sand about quality and choice meaning something to us at a deep level. To attempt to negate that, is to reveal a shocking lack of understanding on what brands mean to people, writes ad man Rayomand J Patell.

By  Storyboard18Dec 1, 2024 8:21 AM
InspiRAYtion 15 - All criticism must be preceded by possession. The Jaguar canard
But to say you can’t criticise something because you will never be an owner is a canard that needs a wee bit of interrogation, writes adman Rayomand J Patell. (Image Source: Simon Furlonger)

There is this conceit that those who critique the Jaguar rebrand cannot afford it.

I’m reserving my comment upon the issue at hand till I see the first new Jag that’s being unveiled.

But to say you can’t criticise something because you will never be an owner is a canard that needs a wee bit of interrogation.

Millions of people watch F1, yet sadly do not have a single car parked in their driveway. Oh dear, how irrelevant they must be.

Porsche a brand that excels at making essentially the same car for the last half century has 99 brand addicts to every 1 owner who may never actually know each model of the 911 released year wise.

For every Ferrari tee wearing 17 year old, chalk up 0.000001 Ferrari owner.

I’m a car guy so these examples flow easier to me. But, let’s look at the world of Art.

I might have something to say about every painting of Monet in the @museeorangerie and yet be only able to afford the tiny set of postcards from the souvenir shop.

I could waffle on about this for a fair amount of time. Bose 901s are the speakers I cherish despite not having a set. I’d love to some day be able to bring home a set of Technics SL 1200s now in their 7th ‘wheels of steel’ iteration. A Lamborghini Countach has been in the garage of my soul since I gained consciousness. Do I have a point of view on the original 1974 edition versus the 25th Anniv Speciale? Of course I do. Do I have a Countach? No.

Brands are our collective aspirations; our hopes and dreams, our line in the sand about quality and choice meaning something to us at a deep level. To attempt to negate that, is to reveal a shocking lack of understanding on what brands mean to people.

Time will tell if Jag will go the Bud Light / Gillette complete annihilation of brand value way. Or, not.

But to negate the feelings of gazillions of fans; that, is a grave travesty.

First Published on Dec 1, 2024 8:21 AM

More from Storyboard18

Brand Marketing

CDAC-Noida and LEGO India join forces to boost India's electronic toy industry

CDAC-Noida and LEGO India join forces to boost India's electronic toy industry

Brand Marketing

Apple set to reveal iPhone SE 4 with full-screen display, powerful A18 chip next week

Apple set to reveal iPhone SE 4 with full-screen display, powerful A18 chip next week

Brand Marketing

Meta rolls out AI-driven tools to revolutionize ad campaign performance

Meta rolls out AI-driven tools to revolutionize ad campaign performance

Brand Marketing

SMFG India Credit unveils new brand film; highlights financial empowerment for SMEs

SMFG India Credit unveils new brand film; highlights financial empowerment for SMEs

How it Works

Zomato rebrands as ‘Eternal’ to embark on new corporate journey: Experts decode the move

Zomato rebrands as ‘Eternal’ to embark on new corporate journey: Experts decode the move

Brand Marketing

Zomato renamed 'Eternal': Memes explode as netizens react to brand's new identity

Zomato renamed 'Eternal': Memes explode as netizens react to brand's new identity

Brand Marketing

ITC to acquire meats startup Prasuma; building a full-stack frozen, chilled and ready-to-cook foods portfolio

ITC to acquire meats startup Prasuma; building a full-stack frozen, chilled and ready-to-cook foods portfolio

Brand Marketing

Britannia's profit rises 5% in Q3, despite subdued demand in FMCG sector

Britannia's profit rises 5% in Q3, despite subdued demand in FMCG sector