Maharashtra State directed by court to prevent misuse of public funds on govt ads

Bombay HC directs the state of Maharashtra to set up a committee to prevent misuse of public funds on government advertisements.

By  Storyboard18Oct 28, 2024 10:08 AM
Maharashtra State directed by court to prevent misuse of public funds on govt ads
Allegations included improper advertisement placements, unauthorized media engagements and dealings with non-compliant creative agencies.

The Bombay High Court has ordered the State of Maharashtra to establish a three-member committee by December 14, 2024, to oversee the use of public funds in government advertising, ensuring there is no misuse for extraneous purposes. The ruling comes in response to the State's failure to comply with a Supreme Court directive aimed at enforcing strict accountability in government advertising practices.

A bench led by Justice MS Sonak and Justice Jitendra Jain expressed dissatisfaction with the lack of an active committee in Maharashtra, emphasizing that the absence of oversight is unjustifiable. The Court referenced the Supreme Court's decision in the case of 'Common Cause vs. Union of India', which determined that government advertising aimed at promoting the political interests of the ruling party is considered malafide, arbitrary and in violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

This ruling follows a petition filed by the Editors’ Forum, which accused the Maharashtra government and various agencies—including the Bombay Municipal Corporation (BMC), City and Industrial Development Corporation (CIDCO) and Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC) of violating multiple government resolutions regarding advertising practices. Allegations included improper advertisement placements, unauthorized media engagements and dealings with non-compliant creative agencies.

In defense, state representatives asserted compliance with existing guidelines, but the court found their justifications insufficient. The judges highlighted that if the Supreme Court-mandated committee had been in place, they could have directed it to investigate the alleged violations.

The court specifically directed the Chief Secretary of Maharashtra to take personal responsibility for the formation of the committee, emphasizing the need for accountability in public expenditure.

Advocates for the petitioners included SB Talekar, Madhavi Ayyappan, Chagan Thakare and Neha Lalsare, while the State was represented by Additional Government Pleader Abhay Patki. Legal representation for BMC, CIDCO and MIDC was provided by advocates including Dhruti Kapadia and Prashant Chawan.

This ruling marks a significant step toward enforcing transparency and accountability in the use of public funds for government advertising in Maharashtra.

First Published on Oct 28, 2024 9:56 AM

More from Storyboard18

Advertising

Misleading ad case: Kerala HC stays order against Baba Ramdev and Acharya Balkrishna

Misleading ad case: Kerala HC stays order against Baba Ramdev and Acharya Balkrishna

Advertising

Global social media ad spend projected to reach $239 billion in 2025, $273 billion by 2026: Report

Global social media ad spend projected to reach $239 billion in 2025, $273 billion by 2026: Report

Advertising

EXCLUSIVE: CCI examines emails of former IBDF President K Madhavan, key officials

EXCLUSIVE: CCI examines emails of former IBDF President K Madhavan, key officials

Advertising

CCI raids: Cloned data from GroupM, Dentsu puts Big Tech under scanner

CCI raids: Cloned data from GroupM, Dentsu puts Big Tech under scanner

How it Works

Creative control or creative caution? What’s really driving content choices on Indian OTTs

Creative control or creative caution? What’s really driving content choices on Indian OTTs

How it Works

CCI raids could accelerate shift from “media muscle” to “strategic agility”, writes indie ad agency Famous Innovations founder

CCI raids could accelerate shift from “media muscle” to “strategic agility”, writes indie ad agency Famous Innovations founder

Advertising

Hypothesis by OML wins Influencer Marketing mandate for Ather Energy

Hypothesis by OML wins Influencer Marketing mandate for Ather Energy

How it Works

SEBI’s ID mandate for intermediary ads welcomed, but industry seeks stronger AI oversight

SEBI’s ID mandate for intermediary ads welcomed, but industry seeks stronger AI oversight