Centre's IT rules amendment unconstitutional, Bombay HC strikes down fact checking unit

Justice AS Chandurkar said the Information Technology Amendment Rules, 2023, which empowers the Centre to set up fact-check units (FCUs) for identifying fake news online, violates Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution.

By  Storyboard18Sep 20, 2024 7:21 PM
Centre's IT rules amendment unconstitutional, Bombay HC strikes down fact checking unit
The petition was filed by standup comic artist Kunal Kamra against the central government for setting up a fact-checking unit via amendment in the IT Rules.

The Bombay High Court on Friday struck down changes to the IT Rules brought by the Central government that allowed it to set up Fact Checking Units. The government had made the amendments in 2023 giving it the authority to identify and debunk 'fake and misleading' information related to its functioning on social media platforms.

The petition was filed by standup comic artist Kunal Kamra against the central government for setting up a fact-checking unit via amendment in the IT Rules.

Justice AS Chandurkar said the Information Technology Amendment Rules, 2023, which empowers the Centre to set up fact-check units (FCUs) for identifying fake news online, violates Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution.

"I have considered the matter extensively. The impugned rules are violative of Articles 14 (right to equality), 19 (freedom of speech and expression) and 19(1)(g) (freedom and right to profession) of the Constitution of India," Justice Chandurkar said, and struck down the proposed IT amendments.

The expression "fake, false and misleading" in the IT Rules was "vague and hence wrong" in the absence of any definition, he added.

The case had gone to a third judge after a division bench of the Bombay High Court in January delivered a split verdict in this matter. The split verdict in January was delivered by a division bench of Justices Gautam Patel and Neela Gokhale.

While Justice Patel struck down the Rules, Justice Gokhale upheld them. Justice Patel had said the Rules amounted to censorship, but Justice Gokhale had said they did not have any "chilling effect" on free speech as argued. It was the third judge's verdict that came today.

In March, the Supreme Court stayed a notification by the Centre announcing the operational status of its official fact-check unit (FCU). The Supreme Court had said the Centre can't go ahead until the Bombay High Court decides on the constitutionality of the matter.

Kunal Kamra and other petitioners had said the amendments would put unreasonable restrictions on freedom of speech and expression.

The petitioners said the provision would lead to government-led censorship online and empower it to be the "prosecutor, the judge, and in that loose sense, the executioner" of what constitutes the 'truth' online.

First Published on Sep 20, 2024 7:21 PM

More from Storyboard18

Brand Marketing

Meta rolls out AI-driven tools to revolutionize ad campaign performance

Meta rolls out AI-driven tools to revolutionize ad campaign performance

How it Works

Asaram Documentary: SC orders police protection for Discovery Execs, offices

Asaram Documentary: SC orders police protection for Discovery Execs, offices

How it Works

Users cry foul: Apple, HDFC Ergo, Zopper in trouble over 'India Gets Moving' campaign

Users cry foul: Apple, HDFC Ergo, Zopper in trouble over 'India Gets Moving' campaign

Digital

Amazon's ad revenue surged 18%, reaching $17.3 billion in the fourth quarter

Amazon's ad revenue surged 18%, reaching $17.3 billion in the fourth quarter

Brand Marketing

Startup leaders urge OpenAI CEO to slash prices and localize offerings for India

Startup leaders urge OpenAI CEO to slash prices and localize offerings for India

Brand Marketing

OpenAI unveils a subtle yet comprehensive rebrand

OpenAI unveils a subtle yet comprehensive rebrand

Digital

MIB officials meet Telangana govt, TVAGA to discuss WAVES

MIB officials meet Telangana govt, TVAGA to discuss WAVES

Digital

Prasar Bharati’s WAVES OTT collaborates with German Football Association

Prasar Bharati’s WAVES OTT collaborates with German Football Association