BoAt’s ad sinks?: Apple-bashing ad created by Tanmay Bhat gets backlash
The boAt vs Apple ad has taken the internet by storm. Mixed reactions all-round. Is it a good addition to combative ads? Find out.
ADVERTISEMENT
Imagine a bustling Indian household, where a spirited young woman stands her ground, advocating for something she truly believes in. This isn't just any ordinary debate—it's a battle of preferences, a clash of brands, and a testament to individual choice.
While the video ad has been created by Tanmay Bhat, Devaiah Bopanna and team at Moonshot, the print ad is not created by them.
In this ad by boAt, a leading Indian audio brand, the narrative unfolds with a simple premise: the girl wants to use her boAt earphones, but her family insists she stick to a more "brand loyal" option, that the entries family swears by - hinting at the global tech giant, Apple.
The father, a stern figure of tradition and loyalty, argues for the familiar, highlighting the comfort of the known and the trusted. The mother, with a touch of pragmatism, emphasizes the ecosystem and its seamless integration. The grandmother, challenges the status quo, advocating for change and innovation.
Amidst this familial discord, the girl stands firm, not swayed by brand names or ecosystems. For her, it's about the sound, the quality that resonates with her, not just in her ears but in her heart. She chooses boAt.
The ad's message is clear: it's not about blind loyalty or brand names; it's about the experience, the connection, and the love for the product. The tagline, "Don't be a fanboy, be a boAthead," encapsulates this sentiment, urging people to break free from the chains of brand loyalty and explore something new, something uniquely Indian.
While some viewers embraced this message, applauding boAt for its boldness and creativity, others remained unconvinced. There is an all-out online war advocating for and against the ad.
Gabbar Singh, a popular internet figure took to X to share, “Boat asking people to ditch Apple and go for Boat earphones. It’s like OYO mocking Taj hotels. People aren’t booking Taj properties just for comfortable bed & pillows. Similarly people aren’t paying 23000/- just for the sound quality :)”
Boat asking people to ditch Apple and go for Boat earphones.
— Gabbar (@GabbbarSingh) March 31, 2024
It’s like Oyo mocking Taj hotels. People aren’t booking Taj properties just for comfortable bed & pillows.
Similarly people aren’t paying 23000/- just for the sound quality :) pic.twitter.com/VdW0BvFo6n
Netizens emphasized that people don't just buy Apple for sound quality; there's a whole ecosystem and brand experience that comes with it.
Ad and marketing professional Bhatnatually shared on X, “Somewhere a copy writer for boAt has gone home thinking he has 'socked it to Apple' by writing 'no fruits were harmed in making this ad'. And trade portals are reporting it as 'shots fired!'. Again, I am happy for boAt's popularity and wish them more success. Such initiatives will make the brand's current and prospective customers (unlikely to be those who can afford and seek Apple products) happy with their choice. Also mock all you will of the 'Apple ecosystem' but if you've experienced it - the network across iPhone, Mac, iPad, Apple TV and AirPods is desired. Competition cannot simply wish it away. Irony is the creative industry is full of Apple fanboys.”
Somewhere a copy writer for boAt has gone home thinking he has 'socked it to Apple' by writing 'no fruits were harmed in making this ad'. And trade portals are reporting it as 'shots fired!'. Again, I am happy for boAt's popularity and wish them more success. Such initiatives…
— bhatnaturally 🇮🇳 (@bhatnaturally) March 31, 2024
Furthermore, there were criticisms regarding boAt's sourcing of products from China, which led some to question the use of patriotism in the ad's narrative.
Boat vs Apple: pic.twitter.com/WKBgdbX3pg
— Atishay (@atishay_j) March 30, 2024
Another X user, Ishwar Bagga said, "This is for the preparation of April 1(April Fool) - Don’t take the bait."
This is for the preparation of April 1(April Fool) - Don’t take the bait.
— Ishwar Singh (@IshwarBagga) March 31, 2024
Some, on the other hand believed that the ad served it purpose of getting people talking. Bhaskar Majumdar a user on X said, "The ad served its purpose of sparking conversation and drawing attention, even leading to comparisons with Apple, which is quite a feat. It's all about generating buzz and being mentioned alongside top brands, even if the comparison isn't entirely fair. They've gained significant mileage and attention as a result."
The ad served its purpose of sparking conversation and drawing attention, even leading to comparisons with Apple, which is quite a feat. It's all about generating buzz and being mentioned alongside top brands, even if the comparison isn't entirely fair. They've gained significant…
— Bhaskar Majumdar (@Probasibangali) March 31, 2024
Kamal Kumar, another X user said, "@amangupta0303 has achieved what he wanted. People are talking about #boat. He knows his target audience and any publicity is good publicity."
@amangupta0303 has achieved what he wanted. People are talking about #boat. He knows his target audience and any publicity is good publicity.
— kamal kumar 🇮🇳 (@kamalkumarBJD) March 31, 2024
Shridhar V, a user on X shared jokingly, “It’s true. Boat’s noise cancellation is much better than Apple’s. When you wear Boat headphones, nobody around you speaks to you, it gets very quiet.”
It’s true. Boat’s noise cancellation is much better than Apple’s.
— Shridhar V (@iimcomic) April 2, 2024
When you wear Boat headphones, nobody around you speaks to you, it gets very quiet.
A LinkedIn user Roy Menezes shared, “Comparing BOAT to Apple is like comparing Tanmay Bhat to Piyush Pandey.?"
the whole lineup of boat products were copied from JBL https://t.co/vjElll8IkI
— Saharsh (@whysaharsh) April 1, 2024
Noise bhi like mujhe kyun toda 🤣 aur Apple se koi competition nhi hai ek Chinese products ka. https://t.co/gkknydNKJq
— Geek Abhishek (@geekabhishek_) March 31, 2024
They really mentioned “sound” in there 😭😂😂 https://t.co/C6zVjQAYUo
— Prakhar Khanna (@Parkyprakhar) March 31, 2024
Bro, meanwhile Aman gupta is busy in ordering clone Apple Watch Ultra from china with LangoAt branding https://t.co/JOn7Sj5nt2
— ᴛʀᴏʟʟɪɴɢ ɪꜱ ᴀɴ ᴀʀᴛ (@Trolling_isart) March 31, 2024
BTW boAt earphones are also made in China. Like the other brand they are referring to. https://t.co/yuYCvwHaRp
— Pankaj Jangid (@Jangid) March 30, 2024
The ad got people talking, and if that was the goal then it's a good sign, right? The team behind the ad did think different to try and do something better.
