Trump fires U.S. copyright Chief after report criticizes AI training practices

Just days before her dismissal, Perlmutter’s office released a major report that said AI companies can’t freely use online content to train models unless they get proper permission from creators.

By  Storyboard18May 16, 2025 11:14 AM
Trump fires U.S. copyright Chief after report criticizes AI training practices
The Copyright Office’s report warned that using copyrighted works without permission could be illegal. This challenges the tech industry's argument that AI training qualifies as “fair use” — a legal loophole they’ve leaned on to avoid licensing content.

Former U.S. President Donald Trump has fired two top copyright officials, including the head of the U.S. Copyright Office, Shira Perlmutter, shortly after the agency warned tech companies not to use copyrighted content for training AI without permission, CBS News reported.

He also removed Carla Hayden, the Librarian of Congress, who had appointed Perlmutter in 2020. These back-to-back firings have sparked concerns that Trump is trying to influence copyright laws to favor certain tech interests, especially those connected to Elon Musk.

Why were they fired?

As per the media reports, just days before her dismissal, Perlmutter’s office released a major report that said AI companies can’t freely use online content to train models unless they get proper permission from creators. This stance challenges how companies like OpenAI, Meta and Musk’s xAI train their AI tools, often using massive online datasets without clear licenses.

Congressman Joe Morelle called the firing political and said it came just after Perlmutter refused to support Musk’s position. He said there was no legal reason to fire her and accused Trump of interfering with a neutral government office. The Copyright Office’s report warned that using copyrighted works without permission could be illegal. This challenges the tech industry's argument that AI training qualifies as “fair use” — a legal loophole they’ve leaned on to avoid licensing content.

On the other hand, India too is currently debating similar copyright questions. The government has set up a committee to study how AI should be regulated under the Copyright Act of 1957. Some Indian publishers have already taken OpenAI to court, claiming it used books and news articles without permission to train its models.

First Published on May 16, 2025 11:14 AM

More from Storyboard18

Special Coverage

WATCH: MoS I&B Dr. L Murugan on India emerging as a global creative powerhouse

WATCH: MoS I&B Dr. L Murugan on India emerging as a global creative powerhouse

Digital

IICT begins admissions for AVGC-XR programs from August

IICT begins admissions for AVGC-XR programs from August

How it Works

Google pushes back on EU's DMA, citing innovation concerns

Google pushes back on EU's DMA, citing innovation concerns

Brand Marketing

Jockey taps GenZ with trend-first styling; ups spends on digital and Q-Comm

Jockey taps GenZ with trend-first styling; ups spends on digital and Q-Comm

Special Coverage

In Photos: At DES 2025, India charts ambitious course for digital entertainment leadership

In Photos: At DES 2025, India charts ambitious course for digital entertainment leadership

Brand Marketing

Campaign turnaround down 70%, production costs cut by 85%: How Indian brands are letting AI take over creative wheel

Campaign turnaround down 70%, production costs cut by 85%: How Indian brands are letting AI take over creative wheel

How it Works

Ikea dominates digital ads in 2024, retains top spot with 27% impression share: TAM

Ikea dominates digital ads in 2024, retains top spot with 27% impression share: TAM

Digital

Gen Z’s new rules of travel include 7% more solo trips, 10% more UPI payments

Gen Z’s new rules of travel include 7% more solo trips, 10% more UPI payments